A congressional Democrat from Georgia, angry that his head was
photo-shopped onto a picture of a porn star reacted in typical Capitol Hill
elitist fashion: He called for a law banning photo-shopping.
Rep. Earnest Smith wants to make it a crime after being
humiliated by the phony porn image created by a blogger who apparently has fun mocking Smith.
bill would trample on First Amendment rights.
“Everyone has a right to privacy,” he told Fox News.com.
“No one has a right to make fun of anyone. It’s not a First Amendment right.”
people, thousands of blogs (including this one) would have to shut down.
“It is Smith’s understanding of free speech rather than
aesthetics that concern me. His new misdemeanor crime would apply to the alteration
of any photograph that ‘causes an unknowing person wrongfully to be identified
as the person in an obscene depiction.’”
of legal avenues exist to pursue if one feels defamed. Parody, on the other
hand, is often treated as an exception.
GOPUSA suggests that Facebook’s ranks would be considerably thinned if a
law banning mean-spirited photo-shopping was enforced. After all, every White
House photo of the president is clearly marked, in futility, as an image that
cannot be altered or edited.
